A network of airsofters in the Metro Atlanta area.


    Who would win in a fight?

    Share
    avatar
    NJSC
    Admin

    Posts : 2646
    Join date : 2008-12-31
    Age : 31
    Location : Buford, GA

    Who would win in a fight?

    Post  NJSC on 27.01.10 20:43

    So a buddy of mine and I always talk about who would win in a fight, granted we are comic book nerds and our dream battles usually steer toward these characters. So I thought I would make a little off topic game out of it. So we'll pick a scenario and then have discussion about it, then have the next scenario.

    First:
    Who would win in a fight?
    Spiderman or Superman? (Granted Spiderman is from the Marvel Universe and Superman is of the D.C. Universe, but still for arguments sake)


    _________________
    Boom that just happened.
    avatar
    navyseal1000

    Posts : 820
    Join date : 2009-03-27
    Age : 21
    Location : Macon, Georgia

    Re: Who would win in a fight?

    Post  navyseal1000 on 27.01.10 20:45

    I think Superman would win in a fight to be honest, just I always put out cake on him


    Last edited by navyseal1000 on 27.01.10 20:50; edited 1 time in total
    avatar
    Bulldog94

    Posts : 931
    Join date : 2009-04-10
    Location : Newnan

    Re: Who would win in a fight?

    Post  Bulldog94 on 27.01.10 20:46

    NJSC wrote:So a buddy of mine and I always talk about who would win in a fight, granted we are comic book nerds and our dream battles usually steer toward these characters. So I thought I would make a little off topic game out of it. So we'll pick a scenario and then have discussion about it, then have the next scenario.

    First:
    Who would win in a fight?
    Spiderman or Superman? (Granted Spiderman is from the Marvel Universe and Superman is of the D.C. Universe, but still for arguments sake)

    I say superman
    avatar
    NJSC
    Admin

    Posts : 2646
    Join date : 2008-12-31
    Age : 31
    Location : Buford, GA

    Re: Who would win in a fight?

    Post  NJSC on 27.01.10 20:48

    but why? Don't you think that Peter Parker would be smart enough to figure out Superman's weakness?


    _________________
    Boom that just happened.
    avatar
    Bulldog94

    Posts : 931
    Join date : 2009-04-10
    Location : Newnan

    Re: Who would win in a fight?

    Post  Bulldog94 on 27.01.10 20:53

    NJSC wrote:but why? Don't you think that Peter Parker would be smart enough to figure out Superman's weakness?

    yeah but by that time superman would have already taken him out lol
    avatar
    Radar

    Posts : 244
    Join date : 2009-06-27
    Age : 22
    Location : Bremen

    Re: Who would win in a fight?

    Post  Radar on 27.01.10 20:54

    not only that. where does spiderman get the kryptonite?

    Guest
    Guest

    Re: Who would win in a fight?

    Post  Guest on 27.01.10 20:55

    Even so the question is how much time would he have. Does SuperMan just show up out of the blue and fight SpiderMan? Or does SpirderMan already know about SuperMan? If they got into a fight without any knowledge of eachother SuperMan would win, his speed and strength would allow him to dominate SpiderMan, regardless of his Spidey-Sense of acrobatic ability.
    avatar
    Airsoftguy238

    Posts : 1423
    Join date : 2009-03-28
    Age : 22
    Location : College Park

    Re: Who would win in a fight?

    Post  Airsoftguy238 on 27.01.10 20:55

    superman
    i mean come on super is part of his name now if it was super spiderman then it would be a different story
    avatar
    navyseal1000

    Posts : 820
    Join date : 2009-03-27
    Age : 21
    Location : Macon, Georgia

    Re: Who would win in a fight?

    Post  navyseal1000 on 27.01.10 21:03

    Airsoftguy238 wrote:superman
    i mean come on super is part of his name now if it was super spiderman then it would be a different story

    Yeah I think Superman would win by a long shot. He is all original and Spiderman isn't as old which makes him suck more than Superman himself! Idk why I came up with that...

    Guest
    Guest

    Re: Who would win in a fight?

    Post  Guest on 27.01.10 21:10

    navyseal1000 wrote:

    Yeah I think Superman would win by a long shot. He is all original and Spiderman isn't as old which makes him suck more than Superman himself! Idk why I came up with that...

    No. *sprays with water* Bad.
    avatar
    NJSC
    Admin

    Posts : 2646
    Join date : 2008-12-31
    Age : 31
    Location : Buford, GA

    Re: Who would win in a fight?

    Post  NJSC on 27.01.10 21:16

    Aggressor wrote:Even so the question is how much time would he have. Does SuperMan just show up out of the blue and fight SpiderMan? Or does SpirderMan already know about SuperMan? If they got into a fight without any knowledge of eachother SuperMan would win, his speed and strength would allow him to dominate SpiderMan, regardless of his Spidey-Sense of acrobatic ability.

    But even still Spiderman also has his strength, and his spidey-sense. Pre-cognition is a big advantage. Also remember that in 1991 Batman killed Superman, and Batman is not a "super"hero.


    _________________
    Boom that just happened.
    avatar
    Bulldog94

    Posts : 931
    Join date : 2009-04-10
    Location : Newnan

    Re: Who would win in a fight?

    Post  Bulldog94 on 27.01.10 21:20

    NJSC wrote:
    Aggressor wrote:Even so the question is how much time would he have. Does SuperMan just show up out of the blue and fight SpiderMan? Or does SpirderMan already know about SuperMan? If they got into a fight without any knowledge of eachother SuperMan would win, his speed and strength would allow him to dominate SpiderMan, regardless of his Spidey-Sense of acrobatic ability.

    But even still Spiderman also has his strength, and his spidey-sense. Pre-cognition is a big advantage. Also remember that in 1991 Batman killed Superman, and Batman is not a "super"hero.

    yeah but spiderman has a natural ability unlike batman who has hardware tools and gadgets lol haha
    avatar
    NJSC
    Admin

    Posts : 2646
    Join date : 2008-12-31
    Age : 31
    Location : Buford, GA

    Re: Who would win in a fight?

    Post  NJSC on 27.01.10 21:24

    and Peter Parker doesn't have gadgets? Dude he's got gadgets he was a scientist first.


    _________________
    Boom that just happened.
    avatar
    Bulldog94

    Posts : 931
    Join date : 2009-04-10
    Location : Newnan

    Re: Who would win in a fight?

    Post  Bulldog94 on 27.01.10 21:51

    NJSC wrote:and Peter Parker doesn't have gadgets? Dude he's got gad
    gets he was a scientist first.
    true but you don't see spiderman pulling out a gun or chasing someone in a vehicle

    Guest
    Guest

    Re: Who would win in a fight?

    Post  Guest on 27.01.10 23:04

    BatMan used some crazy super suit AND incorporated kryptonite in order to defeat SuperMan however. SpiderMan simply doesn't have the monetary access to such things like Bruce Wayne does, even if he does have the brains for it.
    avatar
    NJSC
    Admin

    Posts : 2646
    Join date : 2008-12-31
    Age : 31
    Location : Buford, GA

    Re: Who would win in a fight?

    Post  NJSC on 27.01.10 23:06

    point taken and understood. Paul next match up is up to you.


    _________________
    Boom that just happened.

    Guest
    Guest

    Re: Who would win in a fight?

    Post  Guest on 27.01.10 23:11

    Wolverine VS. Hulk

    Both have regenerative powers, as well as indestructible properties, but who would truly win?

    It may be one of those unstoppable force vs. immovable object fights, but the way I see it, Wolverine has the adamantium claws, which can literally cut through ANYTHING. If thats true, than he could slice off the Hulk's head, his arms, his legs, cut his torso into a thousand pieces, then set it all on fire. No coming back from that one. And the whole "Hulk Smash" thing wouldn't work out for the Hulk to well because Wolverine's skeleton is adamantium, can't be crushed. However, the Hulk is definitly strong enough to wrench Wolverines skeleton apart, his ligaments arent indestructible, however strong they are due to their regenerative properties, and I'm pretty sure if Wolverine's adamantium skeleton was torn apart his body would replace it with standard BONE structure, which the Hulk could smash, rendering Wolverine not dead but combat ineffective for a while.
    avatar
    Admin
    Admin

    Posts : 2096
    Join date : 2008-12-30
    Location : Acworth

    Re: Who would win in a fight?

    Post  Admin on 27.01.10 23:15

    I personally think that it would depend on where the fight went down. In an open area, I'd give it to the Hulk, but in an urban area, I'd say Wolverine is too quick for The Hulk. It's like a tank vs an infantryman. If they're in an open area with no cover, tank lock on, boom, infantryman is done for. But if the guy's got cover and intelligence, he can use it to his advantage in a 1v1 fight.


    _________________




    If you have any questions, feel free to PM me.
    avatar
    Bulldog94

    Posts : 931
    Join date : 2009-04-10
    Location : Newnan

    Re: Who would win in a fight?

    Post  Bulldog94 on 27.01.10 23:20

    Admin wrote:I personally think that it would depend on where the fight went down. In an open area, I'd give it to the Hulk, but in an urban area, I'd say Wolverine is too quick for The Hulk. It's like a tank vs an infantryman. If they're in an open area with no cover, tank lock on, boom, infantryman is done for. But if the guy's got cover and intelligence,
    he can use it to his advantage in a 1v1 fight.
    I stand with admin on this one...
    avatar
    NJSC
    Admin

    Posts : 2646
    Join date : 2008-12-31
    Age : 31
    Location : Buford, GA

    Re: Who would win in a fight?

    Post  NJSC on 27.01.10 23:20

    Is this with Dr. Bruce Banner or after the two were separated? Or even after the three were fused again?


    Last edited by NJSC on 27.01.10 23:23; edited 1 time in total


    _________________
    Boom that just happened.
    avatar
    navyseal1000

    Posts : 820
    Join date : 2009-03-27
    Age : 21
    Location : Macon, Georgia

    Re: Who would win in a fight?

    Post  navyseal1000 on 27.01.10 23:21

    Bulldog94 wrote:
    Admin wrote:I personally think that it would depend on where the fight went down. In an open area, I'd give it to the Hulk, but in an urban area, I'd say Wolverine is too quick for The Hulk. It's like a tank vs an infantryman. If they're in an open area with no cover, tank lock on, boom, infantryman is done for. But if the guy's got cover and intelligence,
    he can use it to his advantage in a 1v1 fight.
    I stand with admin on this one...

    +1

    Guest
    Guest

    Re: Who would win in a fight?

    Post  Guest on 27.01.10 23:22

    Without seperation. Good old Dr. Banner turns into Hulk.
    avatar
    NJSC
    Admin

    Posts : 2646
    Join date : 2008-12-31
    Age : 31
    Location : Buford, GA

    Re: Who would win in a fight?

    Post  NJSC on 27.01.10 23:28

    I think I'd still give it to Hulk. He has unlimited strength. The Hulk has jumped into orbit,INTO ORBIT! So if needing to just escape then he can. And I think the ligaments would be the downfall of Wolverine. Plus if you add the fact that Dr. Banner has a PhD. in Nuclear Physics and then give him a little preparation it'd be over.


    _________________
    Boom that just happened.

    Guest
    Guest

    Re: Who would win in a fight?

    Post  Guest on 27.01.10 23:38

    Yes but also don't forget how old Wolverine is. While he may not have the memory in his mind his body has an amazing muscle memory, which gives him a very keen instinctual edge over his opponents. He has extremely refined, possibly centuries of fine tuning, reflexes and his regenerative nature causes him to never tire, couple that with his "cut-through-anything" claws and it would be extremely difficult for the Hulk to get his hands on him without losing fingers or limbs.
    avatar
    NJSC
    Admin

    Posts : 2646
    Join date : 2008-12-31
    Age : 31
    Location : Buford, GA

    Re: Who would win in a fight?

    Post  NJSC on 27.01.10 23:53

    He was born at the end of the 19th century.
    And according to The Incredible Hulk 181 even Wolverine's claws cannot harm The Hulk.
    There was an actual series on this called "Ultimate: Wolverine vs. Hulk" In episode 1 Hulk easily destroys Wolverine by ripping him literally in half and then throws the lower half of his body 4 miles away.


    _________________
    Boom that just happened.

    Sponsored content

    Re: Who would win in a fight?

    Post  Sponsored content


      Current date/time is 29.07.17 7:46