Here is my take on it! And this is only my opinion.
The Purpose of a "Members only club" is not to keep people out, It's to get the right people in.If you are the leader of a team,you would not just accept any stranger be part of your crew just because he/she said they wanted to, you would hold open try outs to watch that players style, find out their morals, and their over all compatibility to see if they would be a good fit. To me, this is no different than accepting a Club member....Imagine knowing you were heading to a game where there was a HUGE team of like minded players.
Seems like a win to me. Being that there will be 8 board members who are like minded, but all have different personality's and opinions, there should be a variety of people out there playing. If for some reason someone out there feels guilty for something they have done in the past, and feels they would be declined due to that reason, They are probably correct. But you would be surprised how People can be forgiving and problems can eventually be worked out.. It's never to late for any apology. The way I see this Club growing is Members can bring guests. I have several people in mind to bring out and if they are a good fit with the program, They also can become Members,Then they can bring guests and so on. The concept is Great! I think everyone who reads this has at some point seen a Strange walk on player come onto a field and cause problems. The whole point of this(BESIDES THE LOW COST BONUS) is to eliminate that.
Again, This is only my take on the topic and I know some of you out there value my opinion.